Supplementary Chapter 4 Class 10 NCERT - A Question of Trust

Detailed Plot Summary & Analysis

The story of supplementary chapter 4 class 10 ncert, 'A Question of Trust', revolves around Horace Danby, a fifty-year-old unmarried lockmaker. To everyone in his community, Horace seems like an honest, respectable, and hardworking citizen. However, he harbors a secret passion: collecting rare, expensive books. To fund this costly hobby, Horace robs one safe every year. He plans his burglaries with extreme precision, choosing his targets carefully. This year, his target is Shotover Grange.

While conducting the heist, Horace's plans are interrupted by his hay fever allergy and the sudden appearance of a young, elegant woman dressed in red. She confidently pretends to be the wife of the house's owner. Exploiting Horace's fear of going to prison, she convinces him to open the safe for her because she claims to have forgotten the password combination. Horace, desperate to escape and trusting her status, opens the safe barehanded, leaving his fingerprints everywhere. Two days later, Horace is arrested. The ultimate twist is revealed: the woman in red was actually a clever thief herself, leaving Horace to face the consequences while she escaped with the jewels. This subverts the classic saying that there is 'honour among thieves'.

Character Sketches and Key Concepts

How to Write a Board-Standard Character Sketch

1. Introduce the Character — Start with basic physical and social attributes. For instance, mention Horace Danby's age (50), profession (lockmaker), and his social reputation (good, honest, but not completely honest).
2. Analyze Motives and Habits — Explain what drives the character's actions. Describe Horace's obsession with rare books and his habit of robbing once a year to sustain this passion.
3. Discuss Strengths and Weaknesses — Highlight contradictions. Horace is meticulous and loves animals (knows Sherry the dog's name), yet he is easily manipulated under stress and lacks critical skepticism.
4. Conclude with the Character's Fate — Wrap up by describing how these traits led to their final situation. Horace ends up in prison, reflecting on the bitter lesson of trusting a fellow thief.

Board Exam Tips & Common Mistakes

Common Mistake: Many students lose marks by confusing the lady in red with the actual owner of Shotover Grange. Remember, the real owner is an elderly woman of sixty with gray hair who calls Horace's story nonsense. The lady in red was just another thief.

Key Vocabulary to Include in Answers:

• Meticulous planning: To describe Horace's preparation.
• Sophisticated manipulation: For the lady in red.
• Situational irony: To describe the twist ending.
• Honour among thieves: The central moral theme violated in the story.

Practice Questions with Solutions

• Q: Why does Horace Danby steal every year? Is he a typical thief? A: Step 1: Analyze Horace's motivation. Horace is not a typical thief who steals for regular livelihood or greed. He runs a successful lock-making business and has a good reputation. Step 2: Identify his secret hobby. He loves rare, expensive books, which he cannot afford through his regular income. Step 3: Detail his methodology. To buy these books, he plans and robs exactly one safe every year, securing enough money to last twelve months. Final answer: No, Horace is not a typical thief. He steals solely to feed his passion for collecting rare and expensive books, planning his single annual robbery meticulously so as to maintain his respectable social standing.
• Q: How does the lady in red manage to deceive Horace Danby so easily? A: Step 1: Observe her appearance and behavior. She walks in confidently, speaks to the dog familiarly, and behaves with absolute authority as if she belongs there. Step 2: Note Horace's psychological state. Horace is terrified of being caught and sent to prison, which clouds his judgment. Step 3: Analyze her manipulation. She plays the role of an annoyed mistress who is willing to let him go if he helps her open the safe. Horace, relieved, complies without thinking to put on his gloves. Final answer: The lady in red deceives Horace by projecting supreme confidence, dressing elegantly, and using his fear of arrest to make him open the safe without gloves, effectively framing him while keeping herself safe.
• Q: Describe the twist at the end of 'A Question of Trust'. A: Step 1: Explain the immediate aftermath of the heist. Horace leaves Shotover Grange happy, thinking he has escaped safely and helped the mistress. Step 2: Detail his arrest. Two days later, a policeman arrests him because his fingerprints are found all over the open safe. Step 3: Reveal the final irony. Horace tries to defend himself by saying he opened it for the wife of the owner, only to find out that the real wife is a sixty-year-old gray-haired woman who calls his story a lie. Final answer: The twist is that the charming young lady was not the owner's wife but a highly clever rival thief who used Horace to crack the safe for her, leaving him to take the blame.
• Q: What is the significance of the title 'A Question of Trust' in the context of the story? A: Step 1: Explain the literal meaning of trust in the story. Horace trusts the lady in red completely because of her elegant demeanor. Step 2: Discuss the professional code or 'honour among thieves'. Horace believed that fellow criminals would respect each other's boundaries. Step 3: Connect this to the breakdown of trust. The female thief abuses his trust, showing that in the criminal world, there is no real honor. Final answer: The title is highly significant as it explores how trust can be a weapon. Horace's misplaced trust in the lady in red leads to his downfall, proving that the adage 'honour among thieves' does not always hold true.

Frequently Asked Questions