CBSE Class 12 History Notes — Bhakti-Sufi Traditions

CBSE Class 12 History Theme 6 notes on Bhakti-Sufi Traditions: Alvars, Nayanars, Virashaivas, the Chishtis, Kabir, Nanak and Mirabai, with board exam FAQs.

Chapter Summary

This chapter follows how religious life in the subcontinent changed between roughly the eighth and eighteenth centuries. It traces Brahmanical and local cults merging, the Tamil Alvars and Nayanars, Virashaiva dissent in Karnataka, the arrival and spread of Islam, the rise of Sufi orders like the Chishtis, and the poet-saints Kabir, Nanak and Mirabai, and ends with the sources historians use.

Key Concepts

A Mosaic of Religious Beliefs and Practices

Religion in the subcontinent between the eighth and eighteenth centuries was not a single tidy system. It was more like a patchwork quilt, stitched from many local cults, Brahmanical ideas, and later Islamic practices. Historians describe two broad processes at work. One was the spread of Brahmanical ideas through Sanskrit texts such as the Puranas, which were written in simple verse so that even women and Shudras, who were barred from Vedic learning, could hear them. The other was the way Brahmanas accepted and reworked local beliefs, bringing them into a larger fold.

A famous example is the cult of Jagannath at Puri in Odisha. Local people worshipped the deity as a tribal god, and the image is still a rough wooden form. Over time the deity was identified with Vishnu, and the Puri temple became a major Vaishnava centre. This blending is called the integration of cults.

Sociologists describe the result with the terms 'great' and 'little' traditions. The great tradition is the Sanskritic, textual, Brahmanical one; the little tradition is the local, oral, village one. Neither stayed pure, because each kept borrowing from the other.

Integration was not always peaceful. Tantric practices, which rejected caste and ritual purity, often clashed with Vedic Brahmanical beliefs. Followers of the Buddha and Jainas also differed sharply from Brahmanas, and different devotional groups argued about the proper way to reach God.

Key Points

Examples

Alvars and Nayanars: Devotion in Tamil Nadu

Among the earliest bhakti movements were those of the Tamil country, from around the sixth century. The Vaishnava poet-saints were called Alvars, meaning those immersed in God, and the Shaiva ones were called Nayanars, meaning leaders. They travelled from place to place, singing hymns in Tamil in praise of Vishnu or Shiva at the shrines they visited, and they set many local places on the map of devotion.

These saints came from varied backgrounds. Some were Brahmanas, but others were from cultivating castes, and some were people considered 'untouchable'. Their message was personal love for God rather than ritual correctness, and they often placed devotion above caste. Some hymns even hold that a devoted outcaste is more dear to God than a Brahmana learned in the four Vedas.

Two great collections preserve their words. The Alvars' songs were gathered into the Nalayira Divyaprabandham, often called the Tamil Veda, and the Nayanars' hymns survive in the Tevaram. The poet Nammalvar's Tiruvaymoli is among the best known of the Alvar compositions, and Appar, Sambandar and Sundarar are leading Nayanar saints. The Tevaram was later compiled and gained a sacred standing in temples.

Historians note a tension, though. The saints criticised Buddhists and Jainas, who were prominent in the region, and this rivalry affected how rulers chose their patrons.

Key Points

Examples

Caste, Women Devotees and the State in Early Bhakti

Did bhakti really challenge caste? The answer is mixed. The Alvars and Nayanars gladly accepted devotees of all castes into their circle, and their songs sometimes mock Brahmanical pride. Yet Brahmanas also became prominent in the movement, and the Vedic texts were still treated as authoritative. So bhakti softened caste attitudes without abolishing the caste order. Many of its poets wrote in the language of the people, which made devotion open to all who could sing.

Women devotees also found a place. Andal, an Alvar, composed songs that were sung widely and still are, pouring out her love for Vishnu. Karaikkal Ammaiyar, a Nayanar, was so devoted to Shiva that she chose austere practices, even taking a ghostly form, and her verses became part of the Shaiva canon. She and others moved away from the roles expected of wives and mothers, though they did not question the social order itself.

The relationship with the state was equally interesting. The powerful Cholas, especially from the ninth century, patronised Shaiva and Vaishnava temples, building grand shrines at Chidambaram, Thanjavur and Gangaikondacholapuram. They had Tamil hymns of the saints chanted in these temples, and had images of the saints installed. Rajaraja I is credited with having the Tevaram hymns collected. Bronze sculptures of saints and deities from this age are celebrated works of art.

Key Points

Examples

The Virashaiva Tradition in Karnataka

In twelfth-century Karnataka a powerful new movement arose around Basavanna, a Brahmana minister at the court of the Kalachuri king Bijjala. His followers were called Virashaivas, meaning heroes of Shiva, or Lingayats, meaning wearers of the linga. Lingayats carry a small linga in a silver case on their body and worship Shiva alone as the supreme being.

The Virashaivas argued strongly against caste and the idea of pollution at birth, which Brahmanas had stressed. They rejected the notion that women were polluted by menstruation, and they opposed the Brahmanical rituals and idol worship carried out in temples. They also questioned the theory of rebirth. Instead, they valued marriage of widows, which was not accepted in orthodox society, and they honoured people who worked with their hands as equals.

Their thoughts were expressed in vachanas, short sayings composed in the Kannada language, that were easy for ordinary people to remember. Among the women who composed them was Akka Mahadevi, and another well-known figure was Allama Prabhu. Their sayings were later compiled and are a vital source for the history of the tradition.

Since the community tended to emphasise labour and equality, it gained many followers from the artisan and trading groups. Today the Lingayats remain an important community in Karnataka.

Key Points

Examples

Religious Ferment in North India and the Coming of Islam

In north India during the same period, the Rajput states were dominated by Brahmanical worship, with powerful Brahmana advisers. Alongside them, a number of other religious leaders such as Nathas, Jogis and Siddhas rejected the authority of the Vedas and the temple ritual. They preached renunciation and often criticised caste, and they used the vernacular tongues to reach people. Many of them were from the artisan classes, such as weavers and potters, and they became very influential in towns. Later, saints like Kabir and Nanak built on this ferment.

This was also the period when Islam spread widely in the subcontinent. Arab merchants had already been settling along the western coast, and Arab forces conquered Sind in the eighth century, around 711 under Muhammad bin Qasim. Later, from the eleventh century onwards, Turks and Afghans, such as Mahmud of Ghazni, established control in the northwest, and in 1206 the Delhi Sultanate began.

The Muslim ruling class had to govern a mostly non-Muslim population. To the ulama, the learned scholars, the Shari'a, based on the Quran and the Hadis along with qiyas (analogical reasoning) and ijma (consensus of the community), was the law that should guide all. In practice, rulers could not apply it fully in a land of many faiths. Non-Muslims were treated as zimmis, or protected subjects, who paid a tax called jizya in return for protection, and the rulers often allowed them to keep their own customs.

Key Points

Examples

The Growth of Sufism

Sufism is the mystical stream of Islam. While the ulama emphasised rules and rituals, the Sufis sought a deep personal love of God and followed the Prophet's example. Some turned away from worldly comforts and lived simple lives, a practice that grew in the early centuries after the Prophet's time, partly as a reaction to the growing wealth and worldliness of the caliphate. Mystics such as the woman saint Rabia of Basra and thinkers like al-Ghazali shaped Sufi thought. Mansur al-Hallaj, who declared 'I am the Truth', was executed for his statement.

By the eleventh century Sufism had developed into an organised movement with a rich literature, which was called tasawwuf. Sufis gathered around a teacher or pir, in a hospice called a khanqah. The teacher chose a successor, called a khalifa, to carry on his work. In this way lines of teachers and disciples, known as silsilas, were formed.

Several major silsilas arose, including the Suhrawardi, Naqshbandi, Qadiri and Chishti, named after their founders or places of origin. Sufis used methods like zikr, repeated chanting of God's name, and sama, listening to devotional music. Some did not follow all of the ulama's rules and were called be-shari'a, while those who did were ba-shari'a.

Every Sufi was linked to a pir, and after his death his tomb or dargah became a place of pilgrimage.

Key Points

Examples

The Chishtis: Khanqah, Ziyarat, Qawwali and the State

The Chishti silsila was one of the most influential in the subcontinent. It began in Chisht in Central Asia, and came to India in the late twelfth century with Khwaja Muinuddin Chishti, whose dargah is at Ajmer. Other leading figures were Qutbuddin Bakhtiyar Kaki, Baba Farid, Nizamuddin Auliya and Nasiruddin Chiragh-i Dehli.

The Chishti khanqah, such as that of Shaikh Nizamuddin Auliya in Delhi, was a lively place. It had a big hall, jamaat khana, where people lived and prayed, and where visitors of all backgrounds came for guidance. The shaikh's family lived in a separate space. Free food was served, and disciples were initiated by shaving their head. The shaikh also appointed his khalifas to different towns.

Pilgrimage to the tomb of a Sufi, ziyarat, became very popular, as it was believed to bring blessings, or barakat. Even the Mughal princess Jahanara visited Ajmer in 1643. The popular shrine of Data Ganj Bakhsh in Lahore also commemorates Ali Hujwiri. Singing of devotional songs, qawwali, gave a strong emotional experience, and Amir Khusrau, the great poet, composed in a mix of Persian and Hindavi. Sufis also used local languages, such as Hindavi and Punjabi, and wrote poems like the lullabies and spinning-wheel songs called lori and charkhanama.

Chishtis kept their distance from the state. They accepted gifts that were unasked but did not hoard them; Nizamuddin refused royal grants.

Key Points

Examples

New Devotional Paths: Kabir, Guru Nanak and Mirabai

From the fifteenth century, a new group of poet-saints appeared in north India who spoke directly to ordinary people in everyday languages. Kabir, who lived probably in the fifteenth to sixteenth century and is associated with Banaras, was perhaps raised in a family of weavers. His verses, found in the Kabir Granthavali, the Bijak, and the Guru Granth Sahib, reject idol worship, caste, and the claims of both Brahmanas and the ulama. He spoke of one formless God and used images of Sufi and Nath traditions. Both Hindus and Muslims claimed him after his death.

Baba Guru Nanak, born in 1469 at Talwandi, now Nankana Sahib in Pakistan, was a merchant's son who travelled widely. He settled at Kartarpur by the river Ravi, where he founded a community that shared a common kitchen, langar, and worship, sangat. He taught nirankar, the formless divine, rejected rituals and caste differences, and stressed honest work. His hymns were collected later, and Guru Arjan compiled the Adi Granth in 1604. Guru Gobind Singh added more, producing the Guru Granth Sahib, and founded the Khalsa in 1699.

Mirabai, a Rajput princess of Mewar, married into the Sisodia family but devoted herself to Krishna, composing songs of love for him. She accepted the cobbler Ravidas as her guru. Because she defied family norms, she was persecuted, and tradition says she left the palace.

Similar saints include Sankaradeva in Assam, who promoted Vaishnavism through namghars.

Key Points

Examples

Reconstructing Histories of Religious Traditions

How do historians know about these traditions? They rely on a variety of sources. The first are the compositions of the saints themselves, including vachanas, hymns, and sayings in the vernacular languages, often transmitted orally and written down much later. The second are hagiographies, biographies of saints, which describe their lives with miracles and which are not always literally accurate, yet reflect how followers saw them. For the Sufis, there are malfuzat, collections of the conversations of a shaikh, maktubat, letters written by a shaikh, and tazkiras, memoirs of saints.

Third, there are architectural and material remains such as mosques, temples, khanqahs and dargahs, together with sculptures, particularly the Chola bronzes. Fourth, there are the accounts of travellers and court chronicles, which show how rulers dealt with these groups.

Each source must be treated with care. A hymn may have been edited later, a hagiography may be written to honour a leader, and a court chronicle shows only the ruler's view. Dating poets such as Kabir is hard because many verses were added over time. Language also poses problems, as texts in Tamil, Kannada, Persian and Hindavi need skilled translation.

By comparing different kinds of evidence, historians try to build a balanced picture. This is why reading sources critically matters as much as knowing the stories themselves.

Key Points

Examples

Frequently Asked Questions

What is meant by the integration of cults? Give an example.

Integration of cults means the merging of local deities and practices with the Brahmanical tradition. Brahmanas accepted local gods by identifying them with Vedic or Puranic deities and giving them a place in a larger religious framework. A good example is Jagannath at Puri, a local tribal deity that was gradually worshipped as a form of Vishnu.

Distinguish between the 'great' and 'little' traditions.

The great tradition refers to the Sanskritic, Brahmanical practices based on texts such as the Puranas. The little tradition refers to local, oral and village practices. Historians point out that the two were never fully separate; each borrowed from the other, and this constant exchange created the varied religious landscape of the period.

Who were the Alvars and Nayanars, and what role did they play in the Tamil region?

Alvars were Vaishnava poet-saints and Nayanars were Shaiva poet-saints of Tamil Nadu from about the sixth century. They travelled between shrines singing in Tamil, drew followers from many castes, and emphasised personal devotion. Their hymns were gathered into the Nalayira Divyaprabandham and the Tevaram, and the Cholas patronised temples where these were sung.

How far did early bhakti challenge the caste system?

Early bhakti saints accepted devotees from every caste, including those regarded as untouchable, and some hymns praise a devoted outcaste above a learned Brahmana. Yet Brahmanas remained influential, Vedic authority was not rejected, and caste hierarchy continued. So bhakti loosened attitudes but did not abolish caste, which is why historians describe the challenge as partial.

Explain the teachings of the Virashaiva movement.

Founded by Basavanna in twelfth-century Karnataka, the movement worshipped Shiva alone, with followers wearing a linga on their body. It rejected caste, birth pollution, idol worship in temples and the theory of rebirth. It supported remarriage of widows, valued manual labour, and spread its message through Kannada vachanas composed by men and women like Akka Mahadevi.

What is a silsila, and why was the khanqah important in Sufism?

A silsila is a chain of Sufi teachers and disciples, in which a pir appoints a khalifa as successor. The khanqah was the hospice where a pir lived with disciples. It served as a centre for teaching, prayer, free meals and charity, and it welcomed people of all backgrounds, which helped Sufism gain popular support.

Describe the main features of the Chishti order and its relationship with the state.

The Chishtis, with leaders such as Muinuddin Chishti and Nizamuddin Auliya, ran open khanqahs with a jamaat khana and free food, promoted ziyarat to tombs and qawwali, and used Hindavi in their teaching. They kept their distance from rulers, accepting unasked gifts but not hoarding them, and Nizamuddin refused some royal grants.

Compare the teachings of Kabir and Guru Nanak.

Both preached one formless God and rejected idol worship, caste and ritual. Kabir, a likely weaver of Banaras, used blunt poetry to question both Brahmanas and the ulama, and left no organised community. Guru Nanak formed a community at Kartarpur with sangat and langar, and his followers developed into the Sikh panth.

Why was Mirabai persecuted, and what does her life tell us about bhakti?

Mirabai, a Rajput princess of Mewar, devoted her life to Krishna and ignored her in-laws' expectations of a royal wife. She accepted Ravidas, a cobbler, as her guru, which crossed caste lines. Her family tried to stop her, showing that bhakti could challenge social norms and that women devotees faced opposition.

What kinds of sources do historians use to reconstruct the history of religious traditions, and what are their limits?

Historians use saints' compositions, hagiographies, Sufi malfuzat, maktubat and tazkiras, along with buildings, sculptures and court chronicles. Each has limits: hymns may be edited later, hagiographies mix miracle with fact, and chronicles reflect rulers' views. Comparing different kinds of evidence helps historians form a more balanced picture.

CBSE Class 12 History Notes — Bhakti-Sufi Traditions